What gold?

Men at work Notes: bookkeeping standards of the European (national) Central Banks

ESA 95:  Since 1999, the NAI, in accordance with the obligation imposed by Eurostat, has applied the ESA 95 methodology for compiling the national accounts, instead of the ESA 79 methodology.
This new system gives a more accurate and complete picture of economic developments (1). It also provides a better guarantee of the international comparability of the macroeconomic data.

In the chapter devoted to the international environment, the presentation has also been adapted to the introduction of ESA 95 or its equivalent, the United Nations System of National Accounts (SNA 1993). The new methodology is now very widely used in the sources to which reference is made in the Report, principally the EC and the OECD.

 

Working papers

Men at work A dated chart of the events around the Washington Agreement, source GFMS (Gold-Fields mineral services, 2000 brochure)
This is an image
 

Here a table of the planned sales "as forecasted" on 1999-09-26.

Bank of England UK 345

Notes:

  • UK sold 50 tonnes prior to WAG - total sales 395 tonnes.
    Remaining 345 tons were include.
  • It seems that Switzerland could have 58 tonnes or so to sell after WAG 1 expires to make up the total of 1 300 tonnes.
  • Portugal lost 90 tons in a bad lease, these 90 tons were later decucted from the Swiss allocation.
De Nederlandsche Bank NL 300
Oesterreichische Nationalbank AT 90
Schweizerische Nationalbank CH 1 242
Deutsche Bundesbank DE 23

Total

  2 000


Who will be selling what gold anyway?

Men at work How much gold is held by the Central Banks is anyone's best guess. Some odd denominations appear in the balances as "above ground reserves", other CBs include leased gold (IOUs) in the published amount of "reserves"... no way to know.
All is left to guessing.
Most stats are flawed as, the amount held by the ECB is either absent, or unclear (ventilated or accounted for twice, worse no distinction between Europe geographical area, European Union or EUR-club.): the EUR club membership requests that the currency be covered by gold for 15% of the value in Euro.
       
       
       
  i in tons in % of total
  Worl official gold 27 415.4 100%
       
  The G3 20 405.2 74.43%
  Euro area 11 504.6 41.96%
  United States 8 135.4 29.67%
  Japan 765.2 2.79%

Source: World Gold Council,
World Gold Holdings Dec 2003 *.pdf
Note: my own totals, excluding double entries.

Where is that gold?

Well, 60 countries have deposited their gold in the vaults of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, this must amount to the 6 653 tons of gold the Federal Reserve reports as holding "under earmark". In the same monthly document, the Federal Reserve reports holding 8 135 tons for US system.

This amounts to 14 788 tons, about the half of the total gold reserves in all central banks in the world.

Here !  For half of it!

Liberty Street 33 New York, NY
This is an image

How much physical gold?

Here we are speculating again:
Some countries have been cleaned out & if one presumes that they've leased/swapped out approx 15 000 tons then they are only holding approx 8 000 tons which is what the US is purported to be holding.

Most recent inventory I know of is a Morgan Stanley Dean Witter Central Bank Directory 2001. Almost 2 years old.

Another set of data is available from the World Gold Council. official holdings as per December 2003.

The central banks were reputed to hold together 29000-30000 tons of gold. (Gold? Gold Equivalents? Leased? Swapped? IOUs?)

No answer for this: in the Euro zone, the gold reserves are labeled Gold and gold receivables which the Belgian CB completes with, The Bank lends part of its gold assets against a guarantee covering the credit risk.

Need of covering the credit risk has been demonstrated by the Portugal CB loss of 90 tons.

So, until proven wrong, I would not add the reserves of the IMF, BIS, ECB, CEMAC or WAEMU to the total of gold as these are merely stocked in the name of national banks, but functionally regulated by the diverse monetary unions. So doing, I have a total of 27 415.4 tons of official gold of which the monetary unions manage 4 221.2 tons.

Traced CB sales:

period country sold remaining Dec 2003
  US ukn 8 135.4
1980 - 1996 Canada 594 6.2
1997 Argentina 124.8 0.3
1997 Russia 31 388.2
July 1997 Australia 167 79.7
March 1998 Belgium 299 257.8
July 1998 Luxemburg 11 2.3
Sept 1998 Czeh Rep. 31 13.7
1999 - 2000 UK 715 313.2
2000 - 2002 Austria 90 317.5
2000 - 2004 Switzerland 1290 1666.2
2000 - 2004 Netherlands 300 800.5
2001 - 2002 Germany 23 3439.5
2002 - 2003 Portugal 90 517.2
Aug 2003 Greece 20 102.2

So, one can say that, there is about 30 000 tons of gold available in the central banks, less what has been leased and at credit risk or sold with postponed payment.
One could also speculate that leased gold has been absorbed by the market to cover the production deficit.

How much is left?

Care to guess? Not me! Ask Frank Veneroso

From what is left, how much would the Central Banks be willing to sell into the markets?

This table and comments by Nick "Sharefin" Laird
US not for sale
Germany sell a bit - lease a lot
France you can't have our gold at any cost
Switzerland ssell it lease it swap it - we're getting rid of it faster than we can find it - can't keep this up
Italy sold, leased, swapped
Netherlands sold & leased all it can
Portugal sold, leased all it can
How much is left?
UK sold & leased all it can
Spain sold and leased all it can
China we want all we can get and buy more
Japan we want to buy more
   
11 countries  control 80% of the reputed CB holdings

So when one adds up what they've got & what's left to sell & who would want to sell into a rising market you see this major problem.

Looking at the production/demand stats - also a looming problem as the CB's have been necessary to feed the deficit.

With little left to sell & burgeoning demand & lowering production the CB's have a major problem in keeping the perception alive that they have plenty to sell & will keep on deeding the deficit .
See Nick's charts of World Gold Production and Demand

Supply       Demand
Mine production 2 609   Jewellers 2 657
Net producers hedging 389   Industrial & dental 381
Total mine supply 2 220   Sub-total above fabrication 3 038
Official sector sales 614   Bar & coin retail investment 314
Old gold scrap 951      
Total supply 3 786   Total demand 3 352
      Balance (surplus) 434
Source: Gold fields Mineral services spreadsheet download at the World Gold Council
Data are the 4 recent quarters ending September 2003
How is supply demand balanced ?
This is an image


Other's opinion:

Julian D.W. Philips
on Safehaven 2003-05-30 No more 'Official Gold Sales: without renewal of Central Bank Gold Agreement  http://www.safehaven.com/showarticle.cfm?id=811

My comment: Julian has a broader list of conclusions and speculations than I have. I mostly agree with them except for a return of a financial system backed with gold. My opinion is that the next financial system will be based on the capacity of a borrower to service the debt and forget about the principal.

Frank Veneroso
An update on The Commodity Case for Gold 2003-09-04
  James Turk
What is Happening to America's Gold 2001-07-23
How Governments Manipulate the Gold Market - A Primer 2003-10-06
 

Newmont open letter 1999-07-07

  How much gold does the Bamk of England still has?
http://www.newmont.com/en/investor/releases/newmont/release.asp?id=168553

OPEN LETTER TO PRIME MINISTER TONY BLAIR

OPEN LETTER TO PRIME MINISTER TONY BLAIR
7/7/1999


    Dear Prime Minister:

                               The Gold Market

    We the undersigned represent some of the largest gold mining companies in
the world.  The recent sharp fall in the price of gold, particularly since the
announcement by the British government of its intention to sell more than half
of its gold reserves, is naturally of great concern to us.  In our opinion, it
threatens the financial stability of those developing nations who produce
gold.  It is also our perception that the latest downward price movement was
indeed triggered by that announcement.

    On 16 June 1999, in the House of Commons, Mr. Quentin Davies, from the
Opposition Front Bench, speaking in the debate on gold sales, said that there
is a persistent rumor concerning the position of international investment
banks.  Mr. Davies said:

         "...We cannot allow the rumors to grow, because they are extremely
     dangerous to public confidence.  It has been suggested that the market is
     very short of gold, that the short positions may be a substantial
     multiple of the total amount of gold currently held by the Bank of
     England, and that the Bank's real motive is to save the bacon of firms
     that are running those short positions.  ...Has the Government's whole
     plan been simply to drive down the gold price by whatever means, fair or
     foul, to save the position of certain figures in the city which,
     apparently, are so short and potentially in such trouble?"

    The fact these rumors stem from the timing of your government's
announcement, coupled with the methodology selected to conduct the sale, leads
us to ask your government's assistance in this matter.  We believe it would be
helpful for you to make a public denial of these rumors or investigate them
publicly.

    Yours faithfully,

    Ronald C. Cambre, Chairmen, President and C.E.O, Newmont Mining
     Corporation, USA
    John M. Willson, President and C.E.O., Placer Dome Inc., Canada
    Sam E.K. Jonah, Chief Executive, Ashanti Goldfields, Ghana
    Chris M.T. Thompson, Chairman, Gold Fields Limited, South Africa
    Jack E. Thompson, Chairman and C.E.O., Homestake Mining Company, USA
    R.M. (Bobby) Godsell, Chief Executive Officer, Anglogold, South Africa

SOURCE  Newmont Mining Corporation

Other sources

 

See also:

 

Search tips for gold reserves:

Keywords tips for searches:

  •  "under earmark" :: "deep storage"
 

First posted: 2003-10-07